Cavaliere & Co. Insurance Cavaliere & Co. Insurance 
Indexed Universal Life · IUL One camp calls it the secret to tax-free retirement. The other calls it the worst product in insurance. They’re describing the same product, built two different ways.
Get an IUL ReviewArmandino “Dino” Cavaliere · Independent broker · PA License #1071477
Indexed universal life insurance (IUL) is permanent life insurance with a cash value that earns interest based on a stock market index, like the S&P 500, without being invested in the market. Gains are limited by a cap, participation rate or spread, and a 0% floor means a down year credits nothing instead of a loss. How well an IUL works depends almost entirely on how it’s designed and funded.
I can tell you about the bad kind firsthand, because I own one. More on that below. I’m an independent broker, I design these for clients, and I’ll show you exactly what separates an IUL that works from one that’s guaranteed to fail — including the part about how agents get paid.
Your cash value isn’t invested in the market. Each year the insurer credits interest based on how an index performed, using four moving parts.
The share of the index’s gain you receive. At 80%, a 10% index gain credits 8%.
The most you can be credited in a period, no matter how well the index does.
A percentage subtracted from the gain before you’re credited. “Uncapped” strategies usually use one.
The least you can be credited, usually 0%. When the market drops, you don’t lose value to the market.
How the floor and the cap work
Ten hypothetical index years for illustration only — not actual or projected performance. Policy charges are not shown.
The part most people are never told: caps, participation rates and spreads are not locked in. Every IUL has a current rate and a much worse guaranteed limit, and the company can move between them. Those rates are funded largely by the interest the insurer earns on its bonds, so they tend to follow interest rates, usually a year or two behind.
And the policy charges for insurance and administration every month — in up years and 0% years alike. Those charges are heaviest in the first ten years or so.
Most bad IUL stories come from mixing these up — a policy sold as a savings plan but built like a protection policy. That’s exactly what happened to me.
Permanent coverage with some cash value along the way. Here, a higher death benefit for the premium makes sense.
The opposite design: as little insurance as the tax rules allow and as much premium as the rules allow, so most of every dollar builds cash value instead of paying for insurance.
They’re right when a policy has one or more of these problems:
Most of the lawsuits and horror stories involve these exact problems. None of them is the product itself — they’re design choices. But they’re common enough that you should check for every one.
In 2019, before I was licensed, I bought an IUL through a firm a family member had just joined. It had a $150,000 death benefit and a premium of about $100 a month. Here’s what the paperwork showed — and what I didn’t understand until I became an agent:
Then the growth formula got cut. My strategy started at 85% participation. Over the next three years it was cut step by step to 45%, where it’s stayed, even as interest rates recovered and other strategies on the same policy were treated better. The illustration itself said rates could change “for any reason, including our profit margins.” Nobody called to suggest a different strategy.
When I became an agent in 2022, I looked at it with new eyes and stopped putting money in. A year later I lost my corporate job. That’s when it really hit me: a policy built the right way, a few years in, could have given me something to borrow against during one of the most stressful times of my life — while the rest of my money kept earning. Mine had nothing to give.
Think of it like buying a 10-unit building and only renting out three units. You still pay the mortgage, taxes and upkeep on all ten. That was my policy: insurance costs sized for a big policy, with only about 30% of its capacity being funded. A max-funded policy is the opposite — a building sized to what you can fill, with every unit earning.
The product didn’t fail me. The design did.
— Dino Cavaliere
Agent commissions on an IUL are based mostly on the target premium, and the target premium is set by the death benefit. That means a max-funded design — the one that builds the most cash for you — usually pays me less than an over-insured one. I’ll design it the right way anyway, and I’ll show you the target premium on your illustration so you can see it for yourself.
— Dino Cavaliere
Current rates are easy to compare. What matters more is how a company treats policies already on its books. Some carriers advertise strong rates to new buyers while cutting the rates on existing policies. I look at each carrier’s track record with in-force policies when rates moved — up and down — before I recommend one.
Once a policy has built value, you can borrow against it — for a car, a child’s education, an emergency, or income later in life — usually without the loan being taxed, as long as the policy stays in force and isn’t a MEC.
The honest timing: loans may be available early, but in the first several years the amount you can borrow is limited — charges are heaviest and surrender charges reduce what’s available. Put money in steadily, let it build, and borrow with a plan, not constantly.
The borrowed amount moves out of the index and is charged a set rate, often close to what it earns. Low risk and predictable.
Your full cash value stays in the index while you’re charged loan interest. In good years that can work in your favor. In 0% years you’re paying interest against no growth — which is how policies get hurt.
The risks to respect: borrowing reduces the death benefit; borrow too much and the policy can lapse — and a lapse with an outstanding loan can create a tax bill.
Take any employer match first — that’s money your employer adds. IUL can complement a 401(k): no IRS contribution cap (each policy has its own funding limit), no market-loss years and tax-advantaged access before retirement age. But it carries insurance costs a 401(k) doesn’t.
For pure growth on a limited budget, a Roth often wins in the early years because it has no insurance charges. IUL makes sense when you also want the death benefit, the 0% floor or room beyond Roth limits.
Whole life offers guaranteed cash value growth and, with some companies, dividends. IUL offers more upside and flexibility in exchange for fewer guarantees. It depends on how much certainty you want.
How close is it to its funding limit? Your illustration shows the maximum premium.
Is the death benefit the minimum for your premium — or far above it?
What does the guaranteed column say? Does it lapse, and at what age?
If you can’t answer them, you’re not alone — I couldn’t either about my own. I’ll review any IUL, no obligation: your strategy and rates, your funding, your guaranteed column and your options — keep it, adjust it or move it. Moving a policy can restart surrender charges and the contestability period, so I’ll show you what you’d give up first. Sometimes the answer is “you’re fine.” Either way, you’ll know.
Bring the policy you already have, or start fresh. I’ll show you the numbers that matter — including the target premium and the guaranteed column.
IUL isn’t an investment. It’s life insurance with a cash value that earns interest linked to an index. It can work well for long-term, well-funded goals, and poorly when it’s underfunded or over-insured. Design matters more than the product.
Usually because of policies sold with too much death benefit, too little funding and illustrations at the maximum rate, followed by rate cuts. Those are real problems, but they’re design and sales problems, not the product itself.
Not from market drops, because the floor is usually 0%. But policy charges continue every month, so a policy can lose value in 0% years, especially if it’s underfunded. If it lapses, you can lose most of what you paid in.
An IUL designed with the smallest death benefit the tax rules allow and the most premium the policy can hold without becoming a modified endowment contract, so more of each dollar builds cash value.
Yes. Caps, participation rates and spreads are usually not guaranteed and can change, often with interest rates. Every policy has guaranteed limits; check what yours are.
Yes, but usually not all at once. Every policy has a limit on how much can go in during the first seven years without it becoming a modified endowment contract and losing tax advantages. A large lump sum is typically spread over several years, often four or five.
Loans may be available early, but the amount is limited in the first several years while charges and surrender charges are highest. IUL works best as a long-term plan.
Not better, different. Take any employer match first. IUL can complement a 401(k) with no IRS contribution cap (each policy has its own funding limit), a 0% floor and tax-advantaged access, but it carries insurance costs.
Yes, with no obligation. I’ll look at your funding, strategy, rates and guaranteed values, and explain your options, including whether to keep it as is.
Indexed universal life is life insurance, not a security or investment. Cash value growth is not guaranteed; caps, participation rates and spreads can change; policy charges apply; loans reduce cash value and death benefit and can cause a policy to lapse, which may have tax consequences. Tax treatment depends on the policy remaining in force and not becoming a modified endowment contract. This page is general information, not tax, legal or investment advice.